Welcome to The Wishing Well Bar & Grill on A

Good Food, Cold Drinks, and Great Company on County Rd A.

Welcome to The Wishing Well Bar & Grill on A, your favorite neighborhood hangout in Black Creek, Wisconsin. Located at N4510 County Rd A, we pride ourselves on being the go-to spot for a hearty meal, a refreshing drink, and a friendly smile.

Whether you’re stopping by for our famous Friday Fish Fry, catching the game with friends, or just passing through the beautiful Wisconsin countryside, our doors are always open. We offer a relaxed, "come-as-you-are" atmosphere where every guest is treated like a neighbor.

Phone Number: (920) 733-1852

Address: N4510 County Rd A, Black Creek, WI 54106

Opening hours

Mon: Closed

Tue: 11 AM–12 AM

Wed: 11 AM–12 AM

Thu: 11 AM–12 AM

Fri: 11 AM–2:30 AM

Sat: 11 AM–2:30 AM

Sun: 11 AM–8 PM

The Wishing Well Bar & Grill on A Menu

Appetizers

French Fries 3.50 $
Mozzarella Sticks 5.75 $
Jalapeno Poppers 6.25 $
Broccoli Poppers 5.75 $
Cheese Curds 5.50 $
Pork Eggrolls 4.75 $
Onion Rings 4.25 $
Seasoned Criss-Cuts 4.50 $
Stuffed Spudz 4.50 $
Buffalo Wings (10) 12.50 $
Garlic Bread Curds 5.95 $
Bacon Cheese Curds 5.95 $

Sandwiches

The "Fran Burger" 9.75 $
"Wwii Burger" 10.75 $
"Chopped Steak" 8.50 $
Hamburger 8.75 $
Cheese Burger 9.25 $
Bacon Cheeseburger 10.25 $
Classic Blt 8.50 $
Fish Sandwich 7.75 $
Grilled Cheese 7.25 $
Mushroom N Swiss 9.75 $
Ribeye Steak Sandwich 12.25 $
Grilled Chicken Breast 8.95 $
Breaded Chicken Breast 8.95 $

The Wishing Well Bar & Grill on A Photos

The Wishing Well Bar & Grill on A photo 1

The Wishing Well Bar & Grill on A photo 2

The Wishing Well Bar & Grill on A photo 3

The Wishing Well Bar & Grill on A photo 4

The Wishing Well Bar & Grill on A photo 5

The Wishing Well Bar & Grill on A photo 6

The Wishing Well Bar & Grill on A photo 7

The Wishing Well Bar & Grill on A photo 8

The Wishing Well Bar & Grill on A photo 9

Our Story

A Black Creek Tradition.

At The Wishing Well Bar & Grill on A, our story is built on a simple foundation: quality food and genuine hospitality. We believe that a local bar should be more than just a place to eat; it should be the heart of the community.

For years, we’ve been serving the Black Creek area with passion. Our kitchen focuses on the classics you crave—juicy burgers, crispy appetizers, and home-style specials that hit the spot every time. We’ve worked hard to create a space that captures the true spirit of Wisconsin, from our well-stocked bar to our welcoming dining area. When you step into The Wishing Well, you’re stepping into a piece of local history where stories are shared over a cold beer and memories are made around the table.

The Wishing Well Bar & Grill on A – Your Local Favorite in Black Creek!

Located at N4510 County Rd A, The Wishing Well Bar & Grill on A is the quintessential Wisconsin "roadside" destination. Known for its warm hospitality and classic American fare, it’s a place where locals gather and travelers feel right at home. If you’re looking for a genuine taste of small-town Wisconsin, you’ve found the right spot!

Traditional Flavors & Signature Dishes

At The Wishing Well, the food is all about comfort and tradition:

Traditional Wisconsin Flavors: You can’t visit a Wisconsin bar without trying their Friday Fish Fry! It’s a local tradition served with all the classic fixings. Their cheese curds—golden, melty, and squeaky—are also a must-have.
Signature Bites: Their Custom Burgers are the talk of the town, grilled to perfection and topped with fresh ingredients. If you’re feeling extra hungry, look out for their hearty steak specials and homemade pizzas that are perfect for sharing with the whole family.

Ambiance & Experience

The "Neighborhood" Feel: The atmosphere is laid-back, cozy, and unpretentious. With wood-accented interiors and friendly bartenders, it feels like a classic tavern where everyone knows your name.
Community Spirit: It’s more than just a restaurant; it’s a community hub. Whether it's a lively game night on the TVs or a quiet afternoon lunch, the vibe is always welcoming.
Casual Dining: Perfect for a quick lunch, a family dinner, or a late-night drink with friends. The seating is comfortable, and the service is known for being prompt and genuinely friendly.

Pro-Tips for Your Visit

Friday is Fish Fry Day: This is their busiest and most popular time! If you’re planning to visit on a Friday evening, try to arrive a little early to snag a table.
Daily Specials: Always check the chalkboard or ask your server about the daily specials—they often feature seasonal dishes or local favorites not on the regular menu.
Game Day: It’s a fantastic place to watch the Packers or Brewers. The energy is infectious, and they often have drink specials during the big games!

Practical Information

Address: N4510 County Rd A, Black Creek, WI 54106.
Contact: +1 920 733-1852.
Hours: Typically open daily for lunch and dinner, staying open late on weekends (Please call ahead to confirm exact holiday hours).
Payment: Accepts cash and major credit cards.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Is the restaurant family-friendly?

Yes, absolutely! The Wishing Well has a family-friendly atmosphere with a menu that appeals to all ages, making it a great stop for a family meal.

2. Do they offer takeout?

Yes! If you’re on the road or want to enjoy a hot meal at home, you can call ahead to place a takeout order. Their burgers and pizzas travel especially well!